Skip to content
Free shipping on orders over $300
🕒 Wed. thru Sat. 11-5 📍
Over 600 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Reviews GIA-TRAINED - 30+ YEARS IN FINE JEWELRY
Over 600 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Reviews GIA-TRAINED - 30+ YEARS IN FINE JEWELRY

Cart

Your cart is empty

Every ring in this collection carries a story — and we have spent thirty years learning how to read them.

Engagement Rings

Our engagement rings span Victorian solitaires set in warm yellow gold, intricate Edwardian settings alive with milgrain and filigree, bold Art Deco geometric designs, and timeless mid-century classics. Featured stones include old European and old mine cut diamonds, unheated natural sapphires, vivid rubies, and rare colored gemstones sourced through relationships built over decades in the trade.

Every piece has been personally sourced, authenticated, and where needed, expertly restored by master craftspeople we trust. When you choose an engagement ring from Petra Star, you are not just buying a ring — you are choosing a piece of history that belongs to your story now.

Use the filters below to explore by period, stone color, or price. Don't see what you're looking for? We offer custom design and private sourcing — reach out and we'll find it.

Sort by

Filters

Sold outVintage Carnelian and Pearl Necklace 21" Length
Vintage Egyptian Cartouche Pendant 20k Gold
Vintage Letter Charm Written to Edith 14k Yellow Gold
Elegant 14k gold chain necklace with intricate weave, 19-inch length, from The Vintage Vault.
Gold scarab pendant with intricate design, vintage mid-century style, featuring 20K gold, displayed on a neutral background.
Victorian sapphire, diamond, and pearl lavalier necklace in 14K gold from 1900, featuring intricate vintage pendant design
Sold outCushion-Cut Tanzanite Mounting in 14k Yellow Gold - Custom Order
Victorian oval-cut amethyst necklace with silver scrollwork, featuring a 30-carat purple gemstone pendant.
Russian sterling silver cross pendant with intricate scrollwork, vintage-style necklace with detailed religious design.
Vintage 24-inch sterling silver rope chain with intricate twisted design, featuring a polished, classic jewelry style.
Antique silver chrysoprase pendant with intricate vintage design, showcasing a vibrant green gemstone in a detailed silver setting.
14K yellow gold mid-century diamond band ring with 0.42 carats of reclaimed diamonds, featuring a vintage-inspired design.
Saybrook Home Gold and Gems Reuse Service, offering sustainable jewelry recycling and repurposing of gold and gemstones.
Petra Star engagement ring setting in 14k yellow gold with diamond baguette and round brilliant mount, made to order.
Antique Edwardian Dress Stud Charm | Platinum Mother of Pearl Seed Pearl 14K
Diamond Bar Drop Earrings | Earth Mined Diamonds | Share Prong Set | Made to Order 14k Gold or Platinum | Petra Star
Sold outAntique Victorian 14k gold locket pendant with coin edge design and engraved monogram EJR, featuring a detailed vintage style.
Vintage 1970s Acropolis Medallion Pendant in 14K yellow gold with Greek design and Petra Star detail, marked 585.
Vintage 14k gold bagpipe charm with PPLD 585 hallmark, featuring intricate Scottish heritage design, by The Vintage Vault.
Vintage 14k gold mermaid charm with Danish BH 585 hallmark, mid-century figural design from The Vintage Vault.
Vintage German beer stein charm with hinged lid, 8k yellow gold 333 hallmark, mid-century 1960s design, Petra Star by The Vintage Vault.
Sold outVintage Caracas Tranvía charm in 18K yellow gold, featuring a kinetic top and detailed bail, circa 1960.
Upcycled Art Deco diamond chain drop earrings in 18K white gold with Iolite briolettes, vintage bridal jewelry from The Vintage Vault.
Citrine and pearl necklace in 14k yellow gold featuring a pendant with vibrant citrine and lustrous pearls.