Skip to content
Free shipping on orders over $300
🕒 Wed. thru Sat. 11-5 📍
Over 600 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Reviews GIA-TRAINED - 30+ YEARS IN FINE JEWELRY
Over 600 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Reviews GIA-TRAINED - 30+ YEARS IN FINE JEWELRY

Cart

Your cart is empty

Every ring in this collection carries a story — and we have spent thirty years learning how to read them.

Engagement Rings

Our engagement rings span Victorian solitaires set in warm yellow gold, intricate Edwardian settings alive with milgrain and filigree, bold Art Deco geometric designs, and timeless mid-century classics. Featured stones include old European and old mine cut diamonds, unheated natural sapphires, vivid rubies, and rare colored gemstones sourced through relationships built over decades in the trade.

Every piece has been personally sourced, authenticated, and where needed, expertly restored by master craftspeople we trust. When you choose an engagement ring from Petra Star, you are not just buying a ring — you are choosing a piece of history that belongs to your story now.

Use the filters below to explore by period, stone color, or price. Don't see what you're looking for? We offer custom design and private sourcing — reach out and we'll find it.

Sort by

Filters

Stuller ring finger sizer tool for accurately measuring ring sizes with a clear, close-up view of the plastic sizing device.
Finger Sizer Sale price$4.95
Lady's Slipper wildflower seed card by Small Victories, featuring a colorful botanical illustration on a plantable paper card.
Blue Flag Iris plantable wildflower seed card with vibrant blue iris illustration and biodegradable paper for planting
Lavender plantable wildflower seed card from Small Victories featuring a colorful floral design on textured paper.
Winter snowy owl plantable herb seed card by Small Victories, featuring a detailed snowy owl illustration on a plantable seed paper card.
Green Darner Dragonfly plantable wildflower seed card from Small Victories, featuring a colorful illustration on eco-friendly paper.
Small Victories Anna's Hummingbird and Yellow Larkspur plantable herb card with colorful floral design on white background
Small Victories Summer Plovers plantable herb seed card with colorful illustration and biodegradable paper for gardening or gifting.
Bluebird plantable wildflower seed card by Small Victories featuring a colorful illustrated bird and wildflower design.
Petra Star jewelry polishing cloth for silver, gold, and platinum, shown folded with soft fabric and branding visible.
Small Ripple Dish pottery bowl by Dock 6 Pottery, handmade ceramic bowl with textured ripple design, made to order.
Color
Petra Star gift card, a versatile gift certificate with a sleek design, ideal for gifting on special occasions.
Gift Card Sale priceFrom $25.00
Mystic-themed permanent jewelry from Petra Star's Linked by Love collection, featuring sleek, durable gold jewelry design.
Petra Star sword-shaped threader earrings with intricate metalwork, stylish jewelry for a bold, modern look.
Athame Threaders Sale priceFrom $44.00
Vintage Tiger's Eye beaded necklace featuring polished amber-brown stones, handcrafted by The Vintage Vault.
14k gold ribbon charm pendant supporting breast cancer research, featuring a delicate breast cancer awareness ribbon design.
Silver lapis ring, blue enamel earrings, and pendant with modernist design from circa 1990, showcasing vintage jewelry craftsmanship.
Vintage gold-tone costume jewelry brooch pin with intricate design, featuring a classic pin fastening.
14k yellow gold hoop earrings by Jack+G, featuring a classic huggie design with a polished finish.
Hoop Earrings in 14k Yellow Gold Sale priceFrom $55.00
Handmade oval stoneware dish by Dock 6 Pottery, showcasing a smooth, crafted ceramic surface with earthy tones and unique shape.
Color
Pearl nose ring earrings by Petra Star featuring a small, elegant pearl stud for a subtle, stylish nose piercing.
Pearl Nose Ring Sale price$60.00
PS Linked By Love Stars charm, silver-tone jewelry piece featuring star-shaped design and delicate detailing.
Linked By Love Stars Sale priceFrom $60.00
Sold outArt Nouveau silver puffy heart pendant featuring a vintage-inspired design with intricate detailing and a romantic heart shape.
Petra Star reclaimed freshwater pearl charm wrapped in 14k white gold wire, showcasing elegant jewelry craftsmanship.