Skip to content
Free shipping on orders over $300 
🕒 Wed. thru Sat. 11-5 📍
Over 600 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Reviews GIA-TRAINED - 30+ YEARS IN FINE JEWELRY
Over 600 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Reviews GIA-TRAINED - 30+ YEARS IN FINE JEWELRY

Cart

Your cart is empty

Every piece in this collection carries a story — and we have spent thirty years learning how to read them.

Above $1000

Our most significant pieces: important diamonds, rare gemstones, signed designers, and exceptional antique and estate jewelry. We sought out each one for its quality, rarity, and history, and every piece is authenticated and, where needed, restored by master craftspeople. Private appointments are available at our boutique in historic downtown Mystic.

Sort by

Antique Chinese Gold Pendants - Petra Star
Antique Chinese Gold Pendants Sale priceFrom $0.00
Gift Card - Petra Star
Gift Card Sale priceFrom $25.00
Watch Hill Bracelet - Petra StarBracelets
Watch Hill Bracelet Sale priceFrom $175.00
Victorian-Inspired Solitaire Ring - Petra Star
Victorian-Inspired Solitaire Ring Sale priceFrom $780.00
Hemi-Hoop Diamond Earrings 14k Rose Gold Petra Star Designs - Petra Star
Diamond Star Dog Tag Necklace in 14k Yellow Gold - Petra Star
Antique 14K Gold Art Deco Book Pendant — Converted to Three Individual Medallion Pendants — Circa 1930s - Petra Star
22k Black & Gold Slice Cuff With White Diamonds - Petra Star
Herringbone Chain Solid Gold - Petra Star
Herringbone Chain Solid Gold Sale priceFrom $1,030.00
Platinum Diamond Eternity Band with Flush-Set Diamonds (Made to Order) - Petra Star
Diamond Halo Stud Earrings 14k White Gold – .25 cts | Recycled Diamond Studs - Petra Star
Antique 14k Gold Abacus Pendant with Sliding Pearls - Petra Star
Milgrain Pavé Set Marquise Diamond Band - Petra Star
Vintage Cigar Band with Gypsy Set Diamonds in 14k White Gold - Petra Star
Triple-Tier Snake Earrings - Petra Star
Triple-Tier Snake Earrings Sale price$1,100.00
Salt and Pepper Sapphire Ring in 14k Gold - Petra Star
Edwardian Diamond Chevron Ring | Platinum & 18K Gold | Old European Cut | Circa 1900 | Petra Star - Petra Star
Open Circle Diamond Ring - Petra Star
Open Circle Diamond Ring Sale price$1,100.00
Austro-Hungarian Silver & 14K Gold Ring — Emerald, Rubies & Rose-Cut Diamonds, Early-Mid 19th Century
Dreamy Aquamarine Pendant in 18k Gold - Petra Star
Petra Star Wire Cuff Bracelet - Petra Star
Petra Star Wire Cuff Bracelet Sale price$1,150.00
Wide Diamond Link Band – Satin 14k Yellow Gold, 14k White Gold Diamond Accents - Petra Star
14k Gold Antique Diamond Snake Ring - Petra Star
Art Nouveau Griffin Ring | 10k Gold Madeira Citrine | Converted Brooch Ring | Petra Star - Petra Star